Art and game industry veteran Antony Ward aka antCGI)Β loves the idea of being out of the office, maybe travelling or just waiting for a bus, and being able to get out the phone and do some sketching or even continue working on a painting. Of course, you can take a sketchbook with you, but Antony mentions that sometimes you want the added benefits which come with a painting application.
When Antony is in his office, he spends all his time working digitally rather than traditionally. If heΒ΄s out of office and only has a short amount of time, he wants to be able to drop in and work comfortably. Up to now, this dream has evaded him. Antony says that he uses a Wacom MobileStudioPro daily which offers over 8,000 levels of pressure sensitivity. When heΒ΄s then working without this luxury, he feels like painting can be a chore.
We recently sent Antony the Bamboo Fineline 3 stylus for testing, which boasts one thousand levels of pressure sensitivity and can be used on most iOS devices. Meaning you can have the same benefits of painting on an iPad without it having to be a Pro model. Hopefully, this could be the stylus that gives Antony the option to paint and sketch on his phone comfortably. Will it give those on older iPads a new purpose when it comes to working digitally?
Read on to find out what Antony thinksβ¦
Unboxing
“The Bamboo Fineline 3 comes in quite a basic box, but I guess you donβt need anything fancy. On opening it you will find the stylus and some information leaflets, and thatβs pretty much it.
I would have hoped that when paying Β£60 for a stylus there would have been something extras included, a few spare nibs like you get with the Bamboo Sketch would have been nice.”
The Stylus
“The stylus itself is thicker than the Apple Pencil, but it does feel slightly lighter. With that said it still has a good weight and balance when youβre holding it. Wacom have also adopted an ergonomic triangular design, so it fits nicely in your hand and wonβt roll off your desk when not in use.”
“At one end you have the cap which protects the USB charging port as well as an LED light which indicates when the power is on and when the stylus is pairing to your device. At the opposite end, the 1.9mm tip is hidden away inside the barrel, which you twist to make it reveal itself and power on the stylus. I thought this was a nice design element meaning you donβt have unnecessary buttons to press, and you wonβt accidentally turn it on when itβs in your bag or pocket and inadvertently drain the battery.”
“With that said there is a single button which is recessed into the barrel, this can be customized to do whatever you like, depending on the application your using and its support of the stylus. Its also positioned in precisely the right place so I could access it easily with my index finger.”
“Battery power is good and is said to last for fifteen hours on a single charge. In my tests, I can agree that it seemed to last forever and when I left it unused for a week, it had only dropped from 98% to 90% which meant I didnβt have to check the battery level each time I wanted to take it out.”
Touch Screen Use
“This is an active stylus, which means it needs to be switched on to work. When used as a normal pen to take notes or navigate it felt precise and responsive. If you donβt connect it via Bluetooth then youΒ΄re losing out on the pressure sensitivity which is a big selling point for this stylus.
If your using an iPhone which also has 3D Touch, applications like Procreate Pocket now take the pressure information and use it to give you a nice variation in your stroke. With the Bamboo Fineline 3, you will always want to be connected when using it to take advantage of those extra pressure levels. I did some research and 3D Touch uses around 500 levels, so youβre essentially getting double the amount.
If pressure sensitivity isnβt something youΒ΄re interested in then youβre probably better off buying a cheaper model, like the Bamboo Tip which offers similar features minus the pressure sensitivity.”
Digital Art Use
“My focus for this stylus is to draw and paint so I wasnβt interested in how well it takes notes. At the end of the day, if it can sketch nicely, it can write well too.
Also, the applications I was most excited to experiment with were Procreate and Procreate Pocket. Iβm a huge fan of Procreate on the iPad Pro but never had the right stylus to give me the correct amount of pressure sensitivity on the iPhone.
To fully test the stylus, I decided to use the iPad Pro and an older iPad Air 2, just so I could see if there was much difference when working on older hardware. I also tested it with an iPhone 8 Plus but was unable to record this while also working on it as I use it as my main recording device.
The applications I chose to test with were Procreate, Autodesk Sketchbook and Wacomβs own Bamboo Paper.”
“Connecting the Bamboo Fineline 3 to each application was a simple task of opening the options, selecting Connect third-party stylus and then choosing Wacom. You turn the stylus on, press the button on the barrel and your connected.
I then opened each application on both devices and did a series of basic tests, drawing circles, scribbles, straight lines and various other shapes. I triedΒ to Procreate first and straight away I had issues with palm rejection, on both devices. Procreate does have options for checking if a large area is resting on the screen and presumes this is your palm so attempts to ignore it.
To enable this, go into your Settings > Pocket (Or Settings > Procreate if on iPad), and open Palm Support Level. Set this to Palm Support Fine Mode or Palm Support Standard depending on which works best for you.
Even after adjusting these I still had issues, so had to resort to wearing a glove.
On the iPad Pro the stylus worked well, it gave me a nice variation in my strokes and felt quite natural to draw on. The issues came with the older iPad Air 2, where I suffered from lag and wavy lines meaning sketching in Procreate on an older device wouldnβt be an option. At this stage, I assumed this was an issue with the stylus, but I continued with my tests.”
“Next was Autodesk Sketchbook and I have to say, on the iPad Pro this felt much nicer to work with, better than Procreate which surprised me. Even palm rejection worked well too, meaning I didnβt need to wear a glove as I worked. I then turned to the older iPad expecting to see wavy lines again but was pleasantly surprised by the results I got. It was pretty much on par with the newer iPad.”
“This gave me high hopes as it meant the issues I had previously were with software and not the hardware.
Finally, I turned to Bamboo Paper and again this worked nicely on both devices, giving me great levels of pressure sensitivity along with good palm rejection.”
“From these tests, I concluded that the Bamboo Fineline 3 is a great stylus which works across multiple devices, and Autodesk Sketchbook came out on top as the better application to use with it on both older and newer iPads.”
Should you invest?
“There are so many styli available to buy now your pretty much spoilt for choice, but when deciding it comes down to just one question, what will you be using it for? If like me, you are wanting to sketch or paint and have a nice degree of pressure sensitivity then this could be just what you need. At Β£60 itβs not the most expensive stylus available and itΒ΄s much cheaper than the Apple Pencil.
Whatβs more, it will work across multiple devices, unlike AppleΒ΄s stylus, so if your someone wanting to sketch and paint digitally you no longer have to save for an iPad Pro. Why not investigate buying an older device and a Bamboo Fineline 3 instead?
As an alternative option, if youβre looking for a higher degree of pressure sensitivity and two programmable buttons instead of one, you could look at the Bamboo Sketch. It does come with a higher price tag of Β£75, but it has double the number of pressure levels and comes with a nice carry case and extra nibs.”
“Although Wacom supplied the device for me to test, the opinions offered in this review are my own.”
Antony working at his desk
